I recently had the necessity to attend Sunday Mass at an ugly church. One that I have a particular distaste for, one that usually leaves me fuming with anger and resentment at the people who came before us. This time was different, as I sat in the mostly empty church, visually assaulted by its lack of meaningful Christian imagery, and besieged by its uninspiring music, a question broke through the fog of anger: Where did everyone go?
This Church, as ugly as it is, was once popular, it drew people from the local community and beyond, but on this occasion it was only about a third full. As I wondered where the people had gone, Mr. Riley Kane’s recent article, Vote Every Day, came to mind. The article was a meditation on the way that we have boiled down our civic duty to filling in a scantron once every year or two. As I looked around that mostly empty church, I couldn’t help but think of his commentary’s biting accuracy. He may have even understated the problem. It wasn’t just that we had reduced our civic duty, it is that we have trimmed down every duty. Our practice of religion is cut down to the grudging Sunday hour, our connection to our family is a couple of awkward holiday parties or family gatherings for mom or grandma’s sake, our friendships are anemic relationships of convenience. We have become a society focused on autonomy to the exclusion of any kind of interdependence.
Mr. Kane identified this issue and mused at what would be possible if we were to “vote every day.” In this, Kane reiterates the old saying: “Vote with your feet.” It’s a worthwhile reminder, but one that may come too late. We have already cast so many “votes.” The outcome of these decades of past “elections” is made manifest as even the once-popular, once-broadly appealing churches now show signs of significant strain.
I experienced a feeling of hope, and a bit of schadenfreude, watching something I dislike wither. But those feelings were short-lived as I thought of the things I love: my men’s group, my own parish, all the different organizations and affiliations I am involved in. They all are experiencing this same issue to a greater or lesser extent. People are voting with their feet, and voting to be alone, unengaged, and unencumbered by the responsibilities of a life in a community.
We all want the burgeoning society that results from an engaged and productive public. Everyone craves the feeling of deep and meaningful connection; it’s natural to want to be included and considered and wanted, but at what cost? No one wants to be the one to put in the time and the effort. To be clear, I am not referring to the herculean effort required to rebuild society as a whole, rather, I am referring to the effort of being the first one to reach out to a friend or commit to a group effort without calculating the obligation down to the finest detail. We have become a self-centered and selfish people, unwilling to be inconvenienced even for the things we want so badly.
As this realization came crashing down on me, sitting in that ugly church, my eyes were drawn to the tabernacle. What is normally the resplendent place of respect in which our Lord resides, in this context, seemed more like a cage. Looking at the small, golden box, a single phrase pressed itself into my thoughts: “I’m still here.” It was immediately humbling. As I sat in that ugly church, one that I felt I was better than, surrounded by a community I looked down upon, I had to face the reality that God, in all His glory and power, still showed up. There He sat, indicting me, showing me that He was still in the trenches, still fighting His way into the darkness and reaching out to each and every one of us each and every day.
It brought to mind a terrible question: what about us? Do we vote with our feet? How have I voted? I think I can say, at least some of the time, I have voted for the right things. I have been a member of the OCIA team at my parish, St. Cecilia’s, for years. I served as an officer for my Knights of Columbus council. I was a local, and now national, officer of the Order of the Alhambra. And I have helped with various other one-time or recurring events. I say this more to establish my experience than to set myself apart as above reproach. Over my years, I have cast many bad votes as well.
But I believe these bona fides allow me to say that most people have a terrible voting record. I see a lot of the same people doing things, and I hear the same reasons why people cannot get involved. Where is everyone? They aren’t voting. Or rather, they are voting against their interests.
There is always a reason not to be involved: calendars are full, work is a drag, and you only get more tired with each passing year. But when we let these excuses get in our way, we are voting against the society we want to build. When the calendar is full with things other than our community, we are voting against having a community. When work takes so much from us that we can’t give to our community, we are voting work supreme. When we are always too tired, we are voting for our own ease over the people in our lives. And, most importantly, when we use our children as an excuse not to be involved, we are voting for them to grow up without a community and teaching them to vote that way too.
Keep in mind, just like the political world, not every vote is for the president. We need to vote for the dog catcher too. You don’t have to start some heroic effort, just get a little involved in one thing and stick to it. Volunteer at your Church, not because it is easy, but because you might be the one sane person on the committee with whom your pastor can share a sideways glance during a frustrating meeting. Join a fraternal organization not to be best friends with all the members, but because you can help make each other better. Get to know the Confirmandi to help welcome them into the Church. Society wasn’t built in a day, and repairing it will take even longer, so pick something and commit. Make it your thing and stick to it for longer than you are comfortable with, it gets easier with time. Then hopefully, when you hear our Lord say, “I’m still here,” you can confidently say, “Me too.”



